Your cart

Neurofeedback, a powerful brain training tool, has been transforming lives for decades now! While it has been conventionally used in clinical settings, it is now available for home use, thanks to remarkable technological advancements.

If the mechanism of action of neurofeedback has intrigued you enough to incorporate this wellness practice into your routine, you're probably trying to choose the best of the multitude of devices available on the market, right? To help you decide, today we'll discuss the differences between Mendi vs NeuroSky MindWave Mobile 2 - their technologies, costs, benefits, and more.

Key Takeaways

• Mendi employs functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS) to measure the activity of your prefrontal cortex through blood flow and oxygenation, while NeuroSky’s MindWave Mobile 2 uses electroencephalography (EEG) that tracks brainwave activity.

• Mendi is praised for its user-friendly design and intuitive app that provides real-time feedback, while NeuroSky's headset can be used with a multitude of apps, being perfect for those who want to diversify neurofeedback sessions.

• Although both are consumer devices, they are backed by scientific research, so make sure to choose based on your goals, preferences, and budget. It is recommended to talk to your doctor before using Mendi or MindWave Mobile 2 if you have any medical conditions.

Mendi vs Neurosky's MindWave Mobile 2: Key Differences

Before purchasing a neurofeedback device, it's of the essence to assess all their features - this will help you understand which one suits your goals and preferences best. Below, you can find a straightforward breakdown of the key differences between Mendi and NeuroSky's MindWave Mobile 2.

	Mendi	NeuroSky MindWave Mobile 2
Primary goal	Focus, stress resilience, overall wellbeing	Focus, stress resilience, meditation
Price	$299	$129.99
Technology	fNIRS	EEG
Measures blood flow	✔	✘
Measures brain waves	✘	✔
Measures heart rate	✔	Unspecified
Gamified experience	✔	Unspecified
Safety	✔	✔
Subscription fees	$0	Unspecified
Number of users	Unlimited	Unspecified
Movement tolerance	High	Low
Noise tolerance	High	Low
Light tolerance	Low	High
Battery life	~5 hours or 60 sessions	~8 hours
Warranty	1-year warranty, 30-day money back guarantee	Unspecified

Technology: fNIRS vs EEG

Mendi employs functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS), a technology that measures oxygenated and deoxygenated hemoglobin levels in your prefrontal cortex. This neurofeedback technology provides a localized view of brain function, offering greater spatial resolution and making it less susceptible to movement. This means slight movements won’t disrupt the readings, allowing for more accurate and reliable data during neurofeedback training. On the other hand, fNIRS technology is sensitive to light, so you'll have to use the Mendi headband in a dimly lit room.

Once the headband collects the data from your prefrontal cortex blood flow, it translates that information into real-time feedback you'll see on the screen - if your concentration levels increase, the ball on the screen rises, providing you with instant reward.

NeuroSky’s MindWave Mobile 2, on the other hand, is an electroencephalography (EEG) device that collects raw EEG data in regard to brain signals - in other words, it measures brain waves. This technology is more vulnerable to movement, so you have to sit completely still while using the device. Unlike fNIRS technology, though, EEG is not sensitive to light.

One thing to consider is that while the NeuroSky device does collect raw data, you'll likely have to find a suitable app that provides data processing so you could visualize your brain activity - your best option is to confirm this directly with the NeuroSky team. Additionally, you'll have to use a suitable app that translates the collected data into real-time feedback related to specific brainwave patterns. For example, there is the Effective Learner app that shows the user's level of focus through six different color coded levels.

Both fNIRS and EEG technologies are equally effective for neurofeedback training - the difference lies in what they measure and how sensitive they are to movement and light.

Design and Ease of Use

Design and ease of use significantly influence user satisfaction and long-term engagement with neurofeedback devices.

As such, the Mendi headband, which has several sensors that must face the forehead, is preferred for its simplicity and user-friendly design, being accessible for users of all ages. Additionally, people have praised Mendi for its intuitive app interface and straightforward operation, which is particularly appealing for beginners. However, the battery life of the Mendi headband is approximately five hours, slightly less than the battery life of MindWave Mobile 2. Nonetheless, users have reported that the device's comfort and ease of use usually outweigh this drawback.

NeuroSky’s MindWave Mobile 2 has a rather straightforward electrode configuration - it features flexible rubber sensor arms, as well as a rounded sensor tip that needs to be placed on the forehead. The lightweight and compact design makes it easy to use at home or on the go. However, the need for precise electrode placement and the inability to move during sessions can be a disadvantage for some users.

One thing to consider is NeuroSky's battery life. Although it is longer than that of Mendi, it works using an AAA battery. This means you'll have to replace the battery after 8 hours of use, which can be an inconvenience for some.

Cost and Apps

Mendi is slightly more expensive than the NeuroSky device, being priced at $299. This higher cost is partly due to its advanced fNIRS technology and user-friendly design. Nonetheless, compared to other devices on the market, this price is still relatively budget-friendly. Plus, it comes with a lifetime app subscription for no additional costs, and the device can be used by multiple people.

In contrast, NeuroSky’s MindWave Mobile 2 costs $129.99, being one of the most affordable neurofeedback devices on the market. However, it doesn't have a dedicated app - this may or may not be a disadvantage. If you don't mind scrolling through the list of supported apps and prefer using the device for a variety of activities, then this is a plus. On the other hand, if you like to keep things simple, this may be a drawback, especially since it can prevent you from staying motivated and keeping your training sessions consistent.

In other words, if you value a single, streamlined app experience, Mendi might be the way to go. However, if you prefer having access to multiple apps and a more affordable entry point, NeuroSky’s MindWave Mobile 2 could be a better fit.

Benefits

Neurofeedback has long been deemed beneficial for numerous mental health conditions, as well as for promoting overall well-being. Both fNIRS and EEG technologies have been widely researched, and their effectiveness in brain training has been the subject of thousands of studies.

Nonetheless, since neither Mendi nor NeuroSky’s MindWave Mobile 2 are medical-grade devices, they should only be used for wellness benefits.

As such, Mendi users can benefit from:

• Improved focus

• Better sleep

• Better mood regulation

• Enhanced cognitive performance

• Improved memory skills

• Overall mental well-being

• Reduced stress and better sleep quality

Conversely, MindWave Mobile 2 users can benefit from:

• Deeper meditation practices

• Varied gamified experiences

• Sense of calm

• Improved focus

• Increased self-awareness

• Reduces stress

• Improved learning speed thanks to the possibility of using learning apps with the headband

Scientific Backup

The use of fNIRS and EEG neurofeedback technologies for cognitive training has substantial scientific backing. Therefore, there is plenty of evidence in the form of research papers and meta-analyses you can rely on to assess the benefits of these technologies.

However, it is also important to check whether the neurofeedback device you plan to purchase has expert endorsements or a scientific study focused on that particular device.

Mendi, for example, has been reviewed by neuroscientists who confirm its adherence to science and the benefits of its advanced technology. There is also a Mendi study you can read to learn more about this device. You can also check the resources on the NeuroSky website about their brain-computer interface technology and EEG electrodes.

All in all, both devices are grounded in scientific brain research, being reliable tools for enhancing mental health and cognitive performance. Whether you choose Mendi or NeuroSky, you can be confident that you are using a device with a strong scientific foundation.

User Experience and Community Feedback

Both Mendi and NeuroSky’s MindWave Mobile 2 have garnered feedback from thousands of users, highlighting their strengths and areas for improvement.

The Mendi device has over 36,000 satisfied users. Many are praising it for its potential to improve focus, as well as for its nicely designed app and headband. Some parents confirmed that their kids loved the device and were very excited about this brain training! Other users reported an improvement in home-work balance and, therefore, reduced stress and a better quality of life.

Some users have reported that it is quite difficult to understand how blood flow is measured and how that data is translated into feedback, which is why the Mendi team is always available to answer any of your questions. If you're unsure about our device's mechanism of action, you can contact us anytime at support@mendi.io.

NeuroSky’s MindWave Mobile 2 also has a loyal client base, with many users highlighting the device’s portability and convenience for at-home brain monitoring and training. Additionally, some have reported that this device is great for meditation. However, common critiques include limited battery life and occasional difficulties with connectivity and syncing with mobile devices. These issues can impact the overall user experience, but the device’s affordability and versatility make the investment worth it.

In conclusion, both devices have generally received positive feedback from their respective user communities. While there are some areas for improvement, the benefits of using Mendi and NeuroSky’s MindWave Mobile 2 outweigh the drawbacks for most users.

Safety and Side Effects

Safety is a vital consideration when using neurofeedback devices at home. Both Mendi and NeuroSky’s MindWave Mobile 2 are generally safe to use when your goal is to improve general well-being.

Since these products are not medical devices, you should not use them to diagnose, treat, or prevent medical conditions. If you have been diagnosed with a medical condition, it's recommended to talk to your doctor before using Mendi or NeuroSky's MindWave Mobile 2.

How to Choose Between Mendi and NeuroSky MindWave Mobile 2

If your goal is just to observe your brain activity and train it through real-time feedback instead of using neuromodulation tools like cranial electrical stimulation, both Mendi and NeuroSky’s MindWave Mobile 2 are excellent choices. They offer unique benefits; just make sure they align with your needs and preferences.

As such, Mendi is an excellent option if you want:

• A straightforward, streamlined neurofeedback experience.

• To improve your focus.

• To enhance overall cognitive performance.

• To improve your stress response and emotion regulation.

• To try an innovative at-home neurofeedback technology.

Conversely, NeuroSky's device is an excellent option if:

• You want a more diversified approach to brain training provided by the multitude of apps the device supports, plus the extra devices the company sells that can be paired with the headset.

• You're looking for a more affordable option.

• You want to practice meditation.

• You want to improve your learning speed.

• You don't mind using replaceable/rechargeable batteries.

• You want to prevent burnout and promote relaxation.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, both Mendi and NeuroSky’s MindWave Mobile 2 are effective at training your brain, thus helping achieve the goals you're striving for. Whichever product you choose, you'll probably notice improvements in concentration, emotion regulation, and stress levels!

If you think Mendi is your go-to choice, now's the perfect time to get your own headband! And if you have any further questions about our product, contact us at support@mendi.io. The feedback we receive from users is invaluable!

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between Mendi and NeuroSky's MindWave Mobile 2?

Mendi uses fNIRS technology to measure blood flow and oxygenation in the prefrontal cortex, while NeuroSky's MindWave Mobile 2 relies on EEG for real-time brainwave monitoring. Mendi is user-friendly and interactive, whereas NeuroSky is more affordable and supports a broader range of applications.

Which device is easier to use, Mendi or NeuroSky's MindWave Mobile 2?

Mendi is easier to use because of its simple setup and intuitive interface, making it accessible to all ages. In contrast, NeuroSky's MindWave Mobile 2 requires more precise electrode placement, and it is not linked to a particular app, so you'll have to choose one/several from their list of supported apps.

Are there any side effects associated with using Mendi or NeuroSky's MindWave Mobile 2?

Using Mendi or NeuroSky's MindWave Mobile 2 is generally safe, but individuals with diagnosed medical conditions should only use them after talking to their doctor. Mendi and MindWave Mobile 2 are not medical devices.

How much do Mendi and NeuroSky's MindWave Mobile 2 cost?

Mendi costs more due to its advanced fNIRS technology, while NeuroSky's MindWave Mobile 2 is a more budget-friendly option for beginners in neurofeedback training.

Can these devices be used to treat mental health conditions like ADHD or depression?

These devices should not be used to treat mental health conditions as they are not medical devices and are intended solely for enhancing mental wellness and cognitive performance. Always seek professional medical advice for mental health treatment.